On December 23, 1991—two days before Christmas—Laurie Show was buried in her prized Penn State sweatshirt, clinging to photographs of high school classmates who lined up 600 strong in freezing rain to say goodbye. Sitting in a nearby jail, charged with the murder of Laurie Show, were three of Laurie’s classmates—Lisa Michelle Lambert, Tabitha Buck, and Lawrence Yunkin. The trials of these three defendants would become a long, twisty tale of lies, conspiracies, and legal battles. This is the murder of Laurie Show. A story of he said, she said, she said.