January 17, 2001. Amityville, New York. Alex Algeri is working at the gym he co-owns with best friend, Paul Reidel. Alex exits the gym to get something from his car and is shot to death. When police have zero clues, they look to his best friend—and then—his best friend’s wife. A twisted tale of sex, love and greed would soon unfold. This is Lee Ann Reidel and the unbelievable case of murder and mistaken identity.